GIST SupportGIST Support Wiki

 
Comparison Genre

This page describes the Comparison Genre, a specific type of Wiki Genre.

Contents

[edit] Purpose

To compare different options. It can be especially useful for comparing hotly debated topics in a meaningful and neutral way.

[edit] Common Elements

This genre typically begins with a description of the different options and, when applicable, a description of why the topic is hotly debated. It then summarizes the key arguments (e.g., pros and cons) for or against the major options. This is often done in a table, as shown below. It should be presented in a neutral tone, even though individuals may have strong personal opinions about certain options. Additional resources from different viewpoints are often referenced at the end.

[edit] Examples

[edit] Common Wikitext

Here is an example of a table that can be used for this genre. This table compares three competing options, but it can be modified to account for fewer or more options.

Treatment 1 Treatment 2 Treatment 3
Brief description An outpatient surgery where... A prescription drug treatment including... An over-the-counter drug treatment including...
Likelihood of success very high. Symptoms not likely to return... very high. Symptoms are reduced while on medication... marginal improvement at best
Cost/Insurance Cost is generally high, but is covered by most insurance plans Cost is not as high as Treatment 1, but copays can be high for insurance plans Cost is minimal and is rarely covered by an insurance plan
Side Effects Scarring and typical short-term side effects associated with general anesthesia. See [link] for more details. Most common ones include nausea, .... See [link] for more details. Generally no side effects, although some people report... See [link] for more details.
Retrieved from "http://gistsupport.medshelf.org/Comparison_Genre"